Why this is so hard to tell — and why that is not your fault
SEO has an accountability problem built into its physics. The work is technical and mostly invisible. Results lag effort by months, so a provider can coast for a quarter before the numbers confess. And the reporting is usually produced by the same people being reported on, using dashboards you cannot open yourself. Owners end up judging the service the only way left to them — a feeling about the phone — and feeling is a bad instrument: call volume moves with seasons, weather, and the economy, none of which your provider controls in either direction.
The way out is to stop judging vibes and start checking artifacts. Real SEO work leaves physical evidence in places you can look yourself: pages that exist, data in accounts you own, changes with dates on them. An hour of checking beats a year of wondering, and the check below is ordered so the most damning findings come first.
Finding 1: you cannot see your own data
Ask yourself one question: can you log in, right now, to Google Search Console and your analytics, with your own credentials? These free tools record which searches surface your site, which pages get clicked, and how visitors arrive — they are the ground truth every report is supposedly summarizing. If the answer is no — the accounts live under the provider's login, or were never set up, or you have 'view-only access' that somehow never arrived — that is not a small administrative detail. It means every number you have ever been shown was unverifiable by design, and the first deliverable to demand is access, before any other conversation. Our primer on Google Search Console for service businesses shows what you will be looking at once you are in.
While you are in there, look at the Pages report: how many pages of your site are indexed? A provider doing coverage work grows that number over time as service and town pages are built. An indexed count frozen since the site launched, on a retainer that mentions expansion, tells its own story.
Teardown: what the monthly report is actually saying
Take the last report you received and sort its claims into three piles. The first pile is vanity metrics: impressions 'up 40%', a chart of hundreds of 'tracked keywords', a traffic graph with no source breakdown. Impressions rise when Google tests your pages for new queries — including queries in towns you do not serve and for services you do not sell — and a provider can harvest that noise into a green arrow indefinitely. Keyword counts are equally soft: ranking 78th for forty new phrases is motion without movement.
The second pile is branded noise: growth in searches for your company name. That growth is real, but it is usually your reputation and your trucks doing the work, not the retainer. The pile that matters is the third: non-branded, in-market evidence — clicks from searches like your service plus your town, the pages gaining them, and above all the outcomes, calls and form requests, trending over a season. If the report never separates the third pile from the first two, it is written to be admired, not audited. Ask for the separation in writing. The reaction to that request is itself a report.
If part of your revenue comes from commercial accounts, our guide to website development for commercial service companies explains what property managers and procurement teams look for before they request a proposal.
The fingerprints real work leaves
Pages. Type site:yourwebsite.com into Google, or check the sitemap, and compare what exists against your contract. If you are paying for service and location coverage, there should be a page for each real service and genuine pages for your core towns — and the count should grow on the schedule the agreement describes. Read one recent page closely: is it written about your company, your work, your area — or is it generic industry text, possibly identical to a competitor's? Real work reads like your business. Bulk work reads like everyone's.
Changes with dates. Ask for a simple change log: what was created, edited, or fixed on your site and profile each month, with dates. Providers doing the work can produce this in minutes, because they track their own tasks. Providers who cannot are telling you there is nothing to log. Then the profile: has your Google Business Profile changed at all — services completed, photos added, categories corrected? For most local companies the profile drives the map results, and a year of retainers that never touched it is a year spent on the smaller half of the problem.
The thirty-minute self-audit, in order
One: get into Search Console and analytics with your own login; note the indexed page count. Two: open the Search results report for the last 90 days, look at the queries list, and highlight every query that is a service plus a place you serve — that short list is your real search business; everything else is weather. Three: open the Pages tab in the same report and see which pages earn those clicks; if your service and town pages earn none and a blog post about a generic tip earns all of them, the coverage you are paying for is not doing the paying work. Four: compare the pages on your site against the deliverables in your agreement, by name. Five: send your provider the change-log request and the branded/non-branded separation request, and calendar their answers.
None of this requires expertise — it requires access and an hour of honesty. And be fair in the judging: a provider three months into rebuilding a neglected site may legitimately show foundation work and modest numbers. What they should never show, at any stage, is an inability to point at what physically exists now that did not exist before they were hired.
If the answer is 'not much': exit like an owner
Before you cancel anything, secure the assets, in this order: the domain registration in your name, the hosting and website logins, admin access to Search Console, analytics, and your Google Business Profile, and copies of any content created for you. Owners who cancel first and ask for logins second discover how much of their presence was registered to someone else. If deliverables in a signed agreement were never produced, say so plainly and in writing; most disputes of this kind settle when the paper trail is calm and specific.
Then decide what the work actually requires going forward — often less than the old retainer pretended. A sound foundation is largely a one-time build: the right pages, the profile, the tracking. Ongoing effort should be a short, nameable list — new pages as coverage expands, monitoring, adjustments — priced like it. That is the shape of our own offer, for comparison: foundation systems from $997 on the packages page, and the optional Growth Engine plan at $497 a month whose contents — new pages and position tracking — are stated in plain words, with everything registered to you and one company served per trade, per market.
The standard to hold everyone to, including us, is simple enough to write on an invoice: show me what exists, in my accounts, that did not exist before. SEO that is real can always answer that. SEO that cannot was never really being done — and now you know how to tell the difference in half an hour.
